Today’s job seekers may not be in a position to make the same demands of yesteryear, but CML Recruitment’s Ben Cooper says that there are significant stakes on offer for lawyers in Asia with the right skill sets. Are you in demand?


It seems like only yesterday that we lived in a world of salary freezes, recruitment freezes and redundancies. In the legal world, junior associates were putting as much effort as possible into looking busy, lest a partner notice that they had suddenly become an unnecessary drain on PEP, whilst partners were scrambling for what little business remained in the market. Meanwhile, in house counsel, especially those in the financial services sector, became acutely aware that they might be perceived as a cost and not a revenue generation centre.

At one point the legal world shared the fear expressed by US leaders that the world economy was going to grind to a halt, and sadly for some lawyers the turbulent economic environment brought redundancies, whilst last year also saw a number of legal recruitment firms lose a large proportion of their staff due to weakening demand. The only areas showing any signs of hiring were litigation, restructuring and insolvency, which are hardly the bastions of in-house counsel, and many firms were opting to retrain lawyers in these specialisms rather than hire externally.

The road to recovery
Luckily, here in Asia we are now well on the road to a recovery which has been borne out of an increase in M&A and capital markets activity. The result of a more buoyant market is an increase in hires into in-house legal teams, whilst activity in Hong Kong, China and other emerging markets in Asia means that private practice lawyers in IPO teams are already back to sleepless nights, cancelled holidays and looking in the mirror thinking, “Why has my face aged ten years in the last three months?” Almost every firm in town is trying to recruit into these active areas and many are now offering significant salary uplifts to attract the best talent. There is undoubtedly a strong preference for Chinese language skills for Hong Kong listings and candidates with appropriate skill sets will find themselves being offered very tempting packages to make lateral moves.

Banking & Finance
So what effect do improved market sentiment and activity levels have on the hiring patterns of in-house teams? In regard to financial services, equity derivatives and structured products – traditional mainstays in the Asian markets – remain areas that require a great deal of legal support, whilst there appears a general consensus that fixed income and especially credit derivatives are areas that will see substantial growth in the next few years.

A number of banks are moving towards highly structured products and need high quality legal support at the early stages of structuring. These products are still very profitable and attractive to investors unafraid to take a risk, yet are now more regulated than ever before, meaning that it is vital the originators are not leaving themselves open to investigations from organisations such as Hong Kong’s Securities and Futures Commission (SFC). Consequently, lawyers with suitable skill sets are currently in very high demand, even more so as there is a shortage of talent in the Asian market. Although a number of these hires are replacements for casualties of the recent financial crisis, we are being increasingly instructed on roles to grow the structured products and derivatives teams for both equity and fixed income, due not only to the continued recovery of Asian capital markets but also in preparation for the continued growth of Hong Kong as a global financial hub, as banks perhaps outgrow the traditional centres of New York and London in the not too distant future.

The large number of clients each bank is in the process of onboarding is evidence of this growth, and this has led to a huge demand for International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) negotiators. Post Lehman, tighter compliance requirements have meant that trades are not going ahead until Master agreements are firmly in place. The dearth of suitably experienced professionals in this area in the region means that banks are having to look further afield whilst also considering the option of training keen junior lawyers into this specialist area, and salaries for ISDA negotiators are now at times on a par or even, in some extreme cases, above those for legal counsel.

Compliance specialists are also experiencing a greater demand for their skills due to a combination of stricter regulations and an ever more cautious approach to transactions. The more difficult roles to fill are product-specific, front office support positions that require specialist knowledge, and although such roles traditionally require local tenure, experience of derivatives and structured products is highly prized and many banks are having to look to London and New York for suitable candidates. To attract the right kind of talent, many compliance professionals are also being offered packages on a par to legal counsel.

Interestingly, the investment banking divisions of the banks are not hiring in tandem with the M&A and ECM teams of private practice. When they do hire, the focus is on very specialist skills, again usually requiring Chinese languages, and the roles are still generally oversubscribed with very strong candidates. On the whole, we are not seeing a huge rise in recruitment to in-house legal teams across the board – each role is very specific to a projected area of development. Even where there is a clear need and justified hiring request, many General Counsel and Heads of Legal are finding it hard to get headcount granted, with even the most junior roles often requiring authorisation from senior management within global head offices.

But what about the areas other than banking? Smaller investment firms, private equity houses and hedge funds are always keen to remain as streamlined as possible and have the luxury of claiming private practice fees against each deal, and so rarely hire heavily in the legal space. Perceived volatility in the market, for example the recent issues in Greece and Thailand, tend to have a more pronounced effect on the value of such funds and so they are rightly more cautious. When the roles do become available, however, they are some of more attractive and interesting in the industry due to their high level of commercial involvement and visibility across the business. Because of the nature of such roles, employers will usually want to see evidence of commercial acumen, either gained in-house or perhaps through an MBA or previous career. Language skills are very advantageous and indeed, essential, for many Private Equity houses, especially those with a focus on foreign direct investment into China.

Commerce & Industry
The recruitment market within sectors other than financial services is also increasingly buoyant. According to Charis Uyecio, principal consultant and Commerce & Industry specialist for CML in Asia, 2010 has seen a considerable increase in movement across the commercial sectors of the in-house recruitment market. “At the moment it is primarily replacing headcount, but we are also seeing growth hires, both for midlevel and more senior positions,” she says. “The technology, telecommunications, and media sectors are exceptionally buoyant, with the majority of multinational corporations and commercial enterprises looking to hire for an increasingly rare and sought-after skill set, whether it is regional experience, specific industry expertise, technical expertise, or relevant language skills. The market has quickly become one where high quality candidates are scarce and this, combined with the pay freezes and low bonuses in previous years, has led to a marked increase in the level of compensation for most new hires.”

Moving forward
We are seeing a cautious return of recruitment into in-house teams, with candidates with the most sought-after skill sets able to demand significant salary increases to make a move. However, candidates are still a long way from the luxurious position they enjoyed in 2006 and 2007, when the option to pick and choose was more common. Employers, on the other hand, need to bear in mind that their competitors may be able to break salary scales to attract the best talent, and to even be in the race hiring managers should confirm that they are able to get both budget and headcount at the earliest possible stage.

To download the Asian-Counsel Article click here

IN-HOUSE OPINION: If you are an in-house counsel and you have a comment or an opinion you’d like to share either on this article or its subject matter, contact us at: inhouse@pbpress.com with the article title in the subject line, stating clearly if you wish your comments to remain ‘Private’ or ‘Anonymous’.

Latest Updates
Who’s Afraid of AI? - Tech Tales with Paul Haswell
Join Paul Haswell, a partner at K&L Gates in Hong Kong, as he explores the transformative impact of technology on the legal profession in his new column for IHC Magazine. Paul offers insights into the challenges and opportunities for ...
Related Articles
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Latest Articles