China (PRC)

Mitigating insider fraud in China


Over the years, companies operating in China have experienced various types of fraudulent activities including theft of physical assets, misappropriation of company funds, corruption and bribery and procurement fraud. While we are seeing China-based companies investing more in financial controls to mitigate fraud, there is a continued increase in frauds relating to IP theft, information theft, corruption and bribery, and conflict of interest in China. In fact, according to the 2015 Kroll Global Fraud Report1, 73 percent of China-based executives were affected by fraud, an increase of six percent from the previous year.The increase in such incidents is partly due to the lack of employee and third party vendor due diligence and proactive data analytics to identify anomalous transactions or behaviour, as well as inadequate compliance training.Unravelling a fraudster
Fraudsters could exist anywhere in any organisation but the risk of such fraud can be mitigated through proactive preventive efforts. In addition, it is important to understand the typical profile of a fraudster in China, to enable an organisation to better protect itself against insider fraud.

Based on Kroll’s experience of cases in China over the past 18 months, a typical fraudster in China is often someone who appears trustworthy, and is smart, articulate, has the ability to think outside the box and lives a lifestyle beyond their means. These fraudsters behave like entrepreneurs, having high tolerance for risk and ambiguity, and a low fear of failure. While they may work hard at their jobs, they generally believe they deserve to be compensated better. This misguided sense of entitlement, coupled with the ‘fear of missing out’, dictates their spending habits, leading them to live beyond their means which often results in a continued search for ever-bigger rewards. Such self-justification/rationalisation also leads to denial of any wrongdoing when committing fraud and such a fraudster may explore multiple opportunities to make a personal gain, ranging from seemingly insignificant employee expense fraud to larger matters such as manipulating or ‘hijacking’ entire sales/distribution channels, and from one-off misappropriation of large company’s assets to frequent small value frauds.

How to combat insider fraud
Here are five key preventive steps an organisation can take:
1. third party and employee due diligence – knowing the background, reputation and financial strength of customers, vendors and employees can allow the organisation to identify and mitigate potential associated risks;
2. fraud risk assessments – a comprehensive fraud risk assessment can enable the organisation to thoroughly evaluate its business operations, identify and manage those processes, internal controls, and procedures which could be subject to higher fraud risks;
3. regular transaction review – transactional data analytics supplemented by regular transaction testing can help the organisation to identify potential fraudulent transactions and evaluate them on a more timely basis;
4. establishment of robust fraud response protocol – the protocol will set out the procedures required to be followed when a fraud or other irregularity is discovered or suspected. It will demonstrate that the organisation is prepared and ready to tackle fraudulent activities if and when necessary; and
5. involvement of experts – an independent forensic expert can help the organisation to investigate and objectively evaluate any matters of concern. An expert can utilise different tools (such as computer & mobile forensic technology and access to various information databases), methods and procedures, depending on the needs and deploy a team within a short time frame.

While the above mentioned steps and insights into the mindset of a typical fraudster in China provide effective preventive efforts, it is critical that such efforts are supplemented by a strong ‘tone at the top’ and ‘zero tolerance’ message from senior management, which should be comprehensively cascaded down throughout the organisation.

–––––––
Endnote:
1. http://www.kroll.com/global-fraud-report

Email: kenny.shek@kroll.com
Website: www.kroll.com

Tags: Due Diligence, Investigations
Latest Updates
IHC Magazine: Dec 2024 issue with Counsel of the Year Awards 2024 and focus on Dispute Resolution
In this issue, we celebrate the IHC Counsel of the Year Awards, featuring insights from winning teams, delve into the future of dispute resolution with insights from in-house counsel, and sit down with Ben Bury, General Counsel of Gammon Construction, ...
Related Articles
Related Articles by Jurisdiction
Inaugural In-House Community gathering in Shenzhen 深圳企业法律顾问大会
The inaugural In-House Congress Shenzhen will be held next week at the Shenzhen Marriott Hotel Nanshan.
Anti-trust risks in group transaction (II)
In the last issue, we discussed group transactions, i.e. multiple companies jointly purchasing or selling products. Group transactions are quite attractive to small and medium-sized companies ...
Latest Articles
IHC Magazine: Dec 2024 issue with Counsel of the Year Awards 2024 and focus on Dispute Resolution
In this issue, we celebrate the IHC Counsel of the Year Awards, featuring insights from winning teams, delve into the future of dispute resolution with insights from in-house counsel, and sit down with Ben Bury, General Counsel of Gammon Construction, ...